John Warner wrote a good piece titled The Emotional Toll of AI in Education.
I highlighted in the above text what I thought was his most important point.
I’ve always been an advocate of creating situations in the classroom where students can see the impact their learning is having, and I think that’s become even more important in the age of Artificial Intelligence. Seeing and experiencing the direct results of their hard work can go a long way towards them not wanting to take AI shortcuts.
Doing this is relatively easy in an ELL class – students can see it everyday in their improved language use in and outside the classroom.
In content classrooms, I’ve done things like give students a vocabulary list before a unit where they’ve checked off word they know and then give them back the same sheet at the end of the unit; have students rewrite their essays from the beginning of the year as part of an end-of-the-year exam;, and had students record reading a passage several times during the year so they can see their fluency improvement.
You can see more ideas at The Best Resources On Student Self-Assessment.
In a twist of irony – considering the topic of John’s article – I asked ChatGPT for other ideas. Here are a few of them:
1. “Before and After” Knowledge Lists ★★★★★
Exactly your idea.
Beginning of unit:
Circle:
- Know it
- Kind of know it
- Never heard it
Repeat the exact same checklist at the end.
Students love seeing improvement.
2. “Can Do” Checklists ★★★★★
Beginning:
I can…
☐ explain photosynthesis
☐ identify metaphor
☐ compare fractions
End:
Students check them again.
ELL example:
I can…
☐ introduce myself
☐ ask questions
☐ describe a picture
3. Confidence Ratings ★★★★★
Before lesson:
Rate yourself
1 = No idea
5 = I could teach it.
Repeat afterwards.
Students often go from
2 → 4
and see the improvement.
4. Prediction vs. Performance
Before quiz:
“I think I’ll score ___.”
After quiz:
“I scored ___.”
Students become much better judges of their own learning.
This kind of self-assessment was one of Hattie’s highest-impact influences.
5. Learning Journals
At the end of each week:
This week I learned…
One thing I couldn’t do Monday but can do now…
One thing I’m still working on…
6. Before-and-After Writing Samples ★★★★★
Have students write about a topic before instruction.
Don’t grade it.
After the unit:
Write about the same topic.
Students compare.
This works beautifully in ELA and science.
7. Reading Fluency Graphs
Students graph:
Words per minute
every week.
Seeing the graph rise is motivating.
8. Vocabulary Growth Charts ★★★★★
Each student has a graph.
Week 1
Known words: 12
Week 2
18
Week 3
27
Week 4
36
Watching the graph climb becomes motivating.
9. “I Used to Think…”
At the end of lessons:
I used to think…
Now I think…
This makes conceptual growth visible.
10. Personal Mastery Tracker
Instead of grades, students color boxes.
Example:
Persuasive Writing
Evidence
🟨 Beginning
🟩 Developing
🟩 Secure
Students see growth across weeks.
11. Error Analysis
Students keep:
“My Favorite Mistakes”
They periodically revisit them and check which ones they no longer make.
12. Unit Progress Thermometer
Post the unit goals.
Students shade in progress as they master each one.
Very effective in elementary and middle school.

