
Overview:
Restrictive school bathroom policies threaten student health and dignity, highlighting the need to prioritize well-being over punishment.
This past weekend, a story ran in People describing an incident in a North Carolina school district in which a student was asked to show proof of her menstruation to be allowed to go to the bathroom. The sixteen-year-old girl was forced to show proof of her cycle on her phone from a tracker, a clear violation of her Title IX rights. In playing a supportive role in the classroom, providing accommodation services and behavioral regulation skills, I often get to have conversations with students that do not have the pretense of expectations or rapport with classroom teachers that limit what students are comfortable sharing, for fear of reprimand, charged as disrespectful and disruptive. Based on years of conversations with students focused on intersectional pedagogy, this story wasn’t shocking. At all.
For years, there have been many sides and facets to bathroom discourse in schools. Many of these conversations relate to poor bathroom conditions in schools and the shortage of necessary products; many of these conversations relate to student safety concerns and the use of drugs or the prevalence of violence in bathrooms; many of these conversations relate to the marginalization of gender queer students and their targeting by state and local policymakers. All of these conversations are important and deserving of their own dedicated studies. However, I want to focus here on restriction. Its nuances, its rationale, and its harmful effects on student health.
There are a number of reasons why bathroom access is restricted, reasons that we can acknowledge given the present conditions in public schools. Whether it’s fights in the bathrooms, vaping and smoking, the buying and selling of contraband, academic dishonesty, or students skipping class, the prevention of these behaviors is essential in schools. That said, these are behaviors and, as such, should be addressed and handled by the administration. Bathroom logs (that are upheld consistently over the course of the academic year), monitoring high flyers, vigilance on cameras and hallway monitoring, and standard discipline procedures are effective responses to these behaviors.
All of the aforementioned behaviors also occur in hallways, across school grounds—obviously, we don’t prohibit classroom transitions for these reasons because teachers are in the hallways and able to monitor these behaviors. For good reason, teachers are not—and should not—be in student bathrooms; that doesn’t meaningfully change the dynamic: bathroom monitoring is still possible, that truth notwithstanding. Working directly in behavioral support, my team has been perfectly capable of effectively addressing these bathroom behaviors without being in the bathrooms themselves. Adequate knowledge and understanding of these behaviors makes that possible. Restriction does not.
Research indicates that the vast majority, 88%, of teachers encouraged students to restrict their bathroom use by holding their urine. Furthermore, a study indicated that 64% of surveyed schools did not have written bathroom policies, leaving bathroom use up to teacher discretion. In theory, we can trust the academic discretion of classroom teachers to adequately and consistently enforce an equitable and objective bathroom policy that fosters the health of students… if we treat teachers as inhuman machines that don’t have countless other jobs and responsibilities that require immediate attention.
Teachers are humans, and the lack of clear policy on this means that circumstances often fall through the cracks. Hundreds of students in every school go to the bathrooms every day. The margin of error here may be scarce on a material level—the occasional story of a student urinating on themselves or showing proof of their menstruation unsurprising though infrequent—though these errors illuminate the problem with our approach to bathroom use at large. While the effects of these policies that make headlines are devastating in the immediate classroom environment, the greatest effects are far more covertly harmful in the long term.
A study at Stanford Medicine found that upwards of 20% of K-5 students experience lower urinary tract symptoms, affected by the gradually developed habits of holding urine and restricting one’s own bathroom use. Another study finds that over 44% of students restrict fluids throughout the school day to avoid restroom use. Too often, in the classroom, I have witnessed students be refused bathroom access due to the point in the lesson, a teacher’s false perception of disrespect, or the general emotional state of the classroom environment.
Furthermore, school policies have restricted bathroom access after a certain number of times, or outright refused students due to histories of behavioral infractions. The instinct for these motions is understandable—and, given how little schools, especially classroom teachers, are supported on addressing behaviors, I hesitate to condemn any educator for this instinct—however, when that instinct becomes action, and it’s harming students, that’s a problem.
On occasion, I’ve heard school staff telling students that their bathroom or water fountain use is unjustifiable since they, as adults, don’t have such problems. What are we teaching students in these instances? As we slowly crawl toward a greater state of intersectional pedagogy and multicultural education, it is vital that educators understand and recognize how we model behaviors and how all of our actions are teachable. Teachers are guardian figures in students’ lives. We are formative adults with whom many spend far more time than parents. We must consider what behaviors we are teaching students through these restrictions.
- Are we teaching them to prioritize their health and well-being?
- Are high-behavior students less worthy of taking care of their bodies? Of bladder care?
- Of hydration?
- Could they be getting the impression that, perhaps, we care more about their test performance than we do their well-being?
Students are disproportionately under-hydrated, why are we disregarding their needs?
Furthermore, let us consider the original story here and discuss the health and wellbeing of menstruating students. Addressing their menstrual health in a timely manner is essential to their bodily well-being. Research indicates that over 46% of students reported period leaks or accidents due to bathroom restrictions, and other studies indicate that restrictive bathroom policies disproportionately harmed students with heavy or unpredictable bleeding. Beyond that, there is a plurality of limited access to menstrual products, with 1 in 3 adolescents in the US experiencing period poverty.
In any endeavor to strive toward an equitable state of public education, in any motion to claim a belief in intersectional pedagogy and multicultural instruction, in any mission statement that “puts students first,” a consideration of how bathroom policy affects and harms students across the board must be had. So, all things considered, what can we do? Well, as mentioned earlier, there are various behavioral approaches that can be taken to address bathroom incidents. Admin presence, monitoring procedures, and bathroom logs can all contribute to reducing bathroom behaviors.
Restriction, however, is not the answer. Teaching children to reject their bodily functions and needs, in an attempt to solve one issue, creates another one entirely, and is disproportionately affecting marginalized students in the process. Increased access to menstrual products and intersectional professional development can effectively help menstruating students have their needs met and avoid putting their health at risk. Encouraging students to build routine by implementing bathroom breaks throughout the school day (not just at lunch or electives), and consistently meeting their bodily needs without having them miss instruction would also greatly help. Student success is important. Their health should come first.
Any conversation on bathroom health and bodily wellbeing in public education would be remiss to exclude a discussion of modeling. Educators aren’t encouraged to take care of our health, either. This doesn’t just negatively affect us; it also models unhealthy behaviors for our students. Communication pathways between teachers, admin, or other supports across teams is essential for when teachers need to use the restroom. Our job should not require a sacrifice of our physical well-being, and schools become toxic workplaces in this process of failing to meet those needs. Holding and restricting our bodily needs for a break or planning period is setting a horrible example for our students, and efforts to increase coverage when teachers require it in the case of emergencies must be more frequent and accessible.
Educators are not machines. We have bodies, and we have needs. Students are not data points. They have bodies, and they have needs. The story out of North Carolina that occurred last month is an extreme conclusion of our continued restriction of bathroom use for students. Address the behaviors without restricting the students’ well-being. Our praxis as educators, and the future of education, must be through the practice of humanization for educators and students. Too often, education is reduced to numbers, and the humanity of the thousands of people, children and adults, in each and every building is lost in the process. Humanization must come first, and our bodies are part of that process.
