It begins with voice, as it must. The Irish folk singer Radie Peat opens her debut solo album, No Human Tongue Can Tell, with a stark rendition of the traditional “Hares on the Mountain,” and her first syllable arrives a beat before the Rhodes piano that joins in accompaniment. Peat is perhaps the finest singer in an ongoing wave of forward-thinking folk artists inclined toward doomy drones, highlighted by acts like Jim Ghedi, One Leg One Eye, and Poor Creature, as well as Peat’s own bands, Lankum and ØXN. The arrangements on No Human Tongue Can Tell are adventurous and frequently surprising, and the production by John “Spud” Murphy is rich with detail. But Peat’s voice, an arresting contralto with the resonance of a bagpipe played en plein air, lives at the center of the album. From that first note on “Hares on the Mountain,” she commands our rapt attention.
Lankum’s 2023 album, False Lankum, also began with Peat’s vocals, and it left her to sing unaccompanied for a full minute. That opening track, “Go Dig My Grave,” has become Lankum’s signature song, and it’s probably the best showcase for Peat’s voice in the band’s discography. Where False Lankum soon becomes an egalitarian affair, with all four members singing harmonies and contributing to the swelling instrumental clamor, No Human Tongue Can Tell keeps its focus squarely on Peat. She plays nearly every instrument herself and builds lush choruses from layers of her own vocals, choices she says were inspired, respectively, by Mike Oldfield’s Tubular Bells and Enya. Peat is a willing and prolific collaborator, but it’s a thrill to hear her sensibility—stridently melodic, even on the droniest songs—undiluted on No Human Tongue Can Tell.
No score yet, be the first to add.
That melodic clarity helps Peat unite these wide-ranging songs and stories. No Human Tongue Can Tell pulls from all over the Irish, British, and American songbooks, reviving standards and obscurities alike, with a focus on tunes with complicated female characters. It’s the job of the record-making song collector to bring their selections into conversation with one another across history, and Peat identifies the threads that bind the 19th-century tune “Still I Love Him,” sung from the perspective of a woman whose husband abuses her but who can’t bring herself to leave, to the 1966 Liam Weldon composition “Dark Horse on the Wind,” a bittersweet lament for the squandered promise of Irish independence.
Elsewhere on the album, women exercise what limited agency they have. The scorned lover of “The Moon and Stars” mentions the herb rue, a kind of folk-medicine abortion pill whose use in inducing miscarriage dates to the Ancient Greeks. The narrator of “Bonnie Boy” loses her beau but keeps her pride. Even the narrator of “Hares on the Mountain” shuns the predatory attention of boys for more bookish pursuits: “But the young men are given to frisking and fooling/So I’ll leave them alone and attend to my schooling.”
Some of the tunes Peat selected for No Human Tongue Can Tell should sound familiar. Shirley Collins memorably recorded both “Hares on the Mountain” and “Bonnie Boy.” “Same Old Man” is the same Karen Dalton classic that Joanna Newsom breathed new life into on Divers, and a line from Lankum’s version of “Willow Garden” gave their 2017 album Between the Earth and Sky its title. Peat seems determined to transform these songs, even as she pays homage to the earlier versions she loves. “Hares on the Mountain” borrows its melodies from Collins’ take, but Peat trades Davy Graham’s acoustic guitar for a trio of vintage keyboards often associated with ’70s prog rock—Rhodes, Wurlitzer, and Mellotron. “Cailín Deas” embeds the well-known “One Morning in May” between a dirge-y (and allegedly cursed) Irish air and an Appalachian old-time tune, all played on a close-miked concertina, the breath groaning through its bellows and into our souls.
The song that undergoes the biggest transformation is “The Moon and Stars,” and in a testament to Peat’s taste and instincts, it’s the best song on the album. What appears in folk music archives as the fiddle tune “Maid Lamenting” becomes a kaleidoscopic trip-hop track, with a skittering Massive Attack drumbeat and spacey keyboard arpeggios that build to a blown-out, crashing finale. It’s powered by a career-best vocal performance by Peat, who cuts through the densely layered mix like a hot knife. Her voice sounds like it could have tumbled out of a Dublin pub at any point in the past 200 years, but in this bold arrangement, she sounds downright futuristic. Yet Peat’s music always returns to the clay it sprang from. When Peat sings the devastating final lines of “The Moon and Stars”—“I laid my head upon a stone/And then I closed my eyes”—she collapses the centuries.

