The Guardian view on welfare reform: time to retire lazy myths and stereotypes | Editorial

This post was originally published on this site.

A speech by the leader of the opposition exemplifies much that is wrong with the way British politics conventionally talks about benefit claimants

There is a big difference between expenditure that is rising and a rise that is “out of control”. The amount Britain spends on social security is in the former category. Too much political rhetoric around the subject assumes that it is in the latter one.

The Office for Budget Responsibility forecasts the growth in welfare spending over the next five years at 0.2%-0.5% of gross domestic product, from £353bn this year to £431bn in 2032. That money might well be suboptimally deployed. There are rival demands on the state’s resources and a reasonable debate to be had about priorities at the Department for Work and Pensions. But that is not the tone of the debate routinely conducted in Westminster.

Do you have an opinion on the issues raised in this article? If you would like to submit a response of up to 300 words by email to be considered for publication in our letters section, please click here.

Continue reading…

Don’t miss these tips!

We don’t spam! Read more in our privacy policy

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Hot this week

“Wicker” and What Straight Women Want

Critic’s Notebook“Wicker” and What Straight Women WantThe monster-romance movie,...

Chris Ware’s Fractal Pandemic Chronicle

Page-TurnerA Cartoonist’s Depiction of the Moment Things Got WeirdThe...

Topics

Related Articles

Popular Categories

News Feed

Young people should get fewer welfare benefits, according to Milburn review on the workforce – UK politics live

Milburn’s review is considering how to address the growing number of young people classified as not in education, employment or trainingThe Alan Milburn report...

This surprise cost could derail your heat pump or EV charger installation. Here’s how to avoid it.

“Electrify everything” has become a mantra in the fight against climate change. Switching a home’s heating, cooling, and other energy-intensive loads from fossil fuels...

Common forever chemicals linked to nearly double the rate of aggressive breast cancer

Women with higher blood levels of two common "forever chemicals" may face an increased risk of developing a particularly aggressive form of breast cancer,...

Climate progressives won the midterms without saying ‘climate’

On October 20, the two candidates running to represent Michigan in the U.S. Senate, Abdul El-Sayed and Mike Rogers, took questions for an hour...

Climate change is coming for the cactus. Yes, the cactus.

The humble cactus is an icon of resiliency. Stuck in a desert with little rain and abundant searing sun, these plants don’t just survive...

Ariana Grande makes red carpet debut with boyfriend Ricky Alvarez in surprise return to the spotlight at Focker-in-Law premiere after announcing hiatus from fame

Her appearance comes after she announced a hiatus from fame in August, following public scrutiny over her weight.

Jazz Saunders breaks down in tears as she announces she’s quit Made In Chelsea and says she needs to ‘heal from traumas’

Made In Chelsea star Jasmine Saunders has announced she's leaving the show.

Maura Higgins reveals she ‘ended up in hospital’ and ‘couldn’t breathe due to swelling’ after painful rib injury after tearful DWTS rehearsals

Maura Higgins has revealed she ended up in hospital after the swelling from her rib injury became so bad she couldn't breathe. 

EXCLUSIVE: Rimowa Has Collaborated With Maison Margiela

WHITE OUT: It’s probably safe to say this is the first time Maison Margiela‘s four white stitches have been threaded through aluminum. Rimowa has collaborated...

You have to go look yourself in the mirror when you by …

"As men we have to, as a unit, players, coaches, everybody, you have to go look yourself in the mirror when you by yourself...

Judi Dench, 91, reveals the full extent of her vision loss as she says her eyesight is now ‘completely blown’ and can no longer...

Dame Judi Dench has revealed the full extent of her vision loss as she says her eyesight is now 'completely blown' and that she...

‘Holding Nothing Back’ – PTT Seeks To Erase All Doubts Against Hamza Rachid At The Inner Circle 38

Following a demanding stretch of adversity, PTT Apichart Farm returns with the urgency of a man who refuses to be denied.Looking to rebound from...

Memphis vs USF Prediction: Can the Tigers Stay in the Title Chase?

Memphis can't lock down a spot in the American Championship with a win over South Florida, but it can take a massive step towards...

Real Madrid project record €1.4 billion revenue for 2026/27 season as Bernabeu and academy drive financial growth

Real Madrid are projecting a record €1.4 billion in revenue during the 2026/27 financial year, potentially surpassing the €1.221 billion they achieved last season.According...

‘Unfinished business’ – Tuchel committed to England

England head coach Thomas Tuchel says he has "no intention" of leaving the job before Euro 2028 regardless of any offers from major clubs.Tuchel...

‘Unfinished business’ – Tuchel committed to England

'Unfinished business' - Tuchel committed to EnglandImage source, Getty ImagesByBen CollinsBBC Sport journalistPublished8 minutes agoEngland head coach Thomas Tuchel says he has "no intention"...

Here’s how Hansi Flick manages Barcelona players and decides rotations

Hansi Flick's approach to managing his Barcelona squad involves considerably more than selecting a starting XI and deciding when to make substitutions.In fact, according...

Popular articles

Young people should get fewer welfare benefits, according to Milburn review on the workforce – UK politics live

Milburn’s review is considering how to address the growing number of young people classified as not in education, employment or trainingThe Alan Milburn report...

This surprise cost could derail your heat pump or EV charger installation. Here’s how to avoid it.

“Electrify everything” has become a mantra in the fight against climate change. Switching a home’s heating, cooling, and other energy-intensive loads from fossil fuels...

Common forever chemicals linked to nearly double the rate of aggressive breast cancer

Women with higher blood levels of two common "forever chemicals" may face an increased risk of developing a particularly aggressive form of breast cancer,...

Climate progressives won the midterms without saying ‘climate’

On October 20, the two candidates running to represent Michigan in the U.S. Senate, Abdul El-Sayed and Mike Rogers, took questions for an hour...

Climate change is coming for the cactus. Yes, the cactus.

The humble cactus is an icon of resiliency. Stuck in a desert with little rain and abundant searing sun, these plants don’t just survive...

Ariana Grande makes red carpet debut with boyfriend Ricky Alvarez in surprise return to the spotlight at Focker-in-Law premiere after announcing hiatus from fame

Her appearance comes after she announced a hiatus from fame in August, following public scrutiny over her weight.

Jazz Saunders breaks down in tears as she announces she’s quit Made In Chelsea and says she needs to ‘heal from traumas’

Made In Chelsea star Jasmine Saunders has announced she's leaving the show.

Maura Higgins reveals she ‘ended up in hospital’ and ‘couldn’t breathe due to swelling’ after painful rib injury after tearful DWTS rehearsals

Maura Higgins has revealed she ended up in hospital after the swelling from her rib injury became so bad she couldn't breathe. 

EXCLUSIVE: Rimowa Has Collaborated With Maison Margiela

WHITE OUT: It’s probably safe to say this is the first time Maison Margiela‘s four white stitches have been threaded through aluminum. Rimowa has collaborated...

You have to go look yourself in the mirror when you by …

"As men we have to, as a unit, players, coaches, everybody, you have to go look yourself in the mirror when you by yourself...

Judi Dench, 91, reveals the full extent of her vision loss as she says her eyesight is now ‘completely blown’ and can no longer...

Dame Judi Dench has revealed the full extent of her vision loss as she says her eyesight is now 'completely blown' and that she...

‘Holding Nothing Back’ – PTT Seeks To Erase All Doubts Against Hamza Rachid At The Inner Circle 38

Following a demanding stretch of adversity, PTT Apichart Farm returns with the urgency of a man who refuses to be denied.Looking to rebound from...

Memphis vs USF Prediction: Can the Tigers Stay in the Title Chase?

Memphis can't lock down a spot in the American Championship with a win over South Florida, but it can take a massive step towards...

Real Madrid project record €1.4 billion revenue for 2026/27 season as Bernabeu and academy drive financial growth

Real Madrid are projecting a record €1.4 billion in revenue during the 2026/27 financial year, potentially surpassing the €1.221 billion they achieved last season.According...

‘Unfinished business’ – Tuchel committed to England

England head coach Thomas Tuchel says he has "no intention" of leaving the job before Euro 2028 regardless of any offers from major clubs.Tuchel...

‘Unfinished business’ – Tuchel committed to England

'Unfinished business' - Tuchel committed to EnglandImage source, Getty ImagesByBen CollinsBBC Sport journalistPublished8 minutes agoEngland head coach Thomas Tuchel says he has "no intention"...

Here’s how Hansi Flick manages Barcelona players and decides rotations

Hansi Flick's approach to managing his Barcelona squad involves considerably more than selecting a starting XI and deciding when to make substitutions.In fact, according...