
Overview:
A math tutor reflects on a powerful teaching moment when sixth-grader Ruby independently discovers the logic behind averages, demonstrating that true learning comes from understanding why an answer is correct.
Educators are blessed in those moments when a student not only knows the right answer, but can explain why the answer is correct. For many educators, the “why” is far more important than the answer itself. The “why” demonstrates an understanding of math’s logic and principles that explain and lead to the answer. “Why” unlocks the door and reveals math’s inner workings. It’s little wonder that “why” is the question asked most often in childhood. It’s asked because we want to understand what is behind the locked door.
Last year, before our first tutoring session, Ruby entered 6th grade as I approached my sixth year of tutoring middle schoolers in math. Exchanging emails with her mom before the first session, I learned that Ruby scored solid As in all her academic subjects except math, where she earned a very respectable B+. Respectable in my eyes, but not in Ruby’s. She is, God bless her, one of those delightful people who wants to improve. Learning is her goal, the grade is just a yardstick. My respect for Ruby has only grown from that moment.
In our first session, before talking about math, I asked Ruby some questions to get to know her. The kind you would ask a new acquaintance you hope will become a friend. Like many students who perform well academically, Ruby has career goals. She wants to become a lawyer and then a judge. After complimenting her on setting long-term goals, I suggested that gaining an understanding of math would help her achieve her goals. Was I suggesting that Euclid was a lawyer? No, but Abraham Lincoln was and he studied Euclidean geometry to help him learn to think logically, a useful skill for lawyers, presidents and just about everybody else.
At the beginning of this year, Ruby’s mom told me that she was looking for a different school for her daughter. Ruby wants to change schools because she feels that too much class time is spent on trying to make students behave and not enough on what they are supposed to learn. Did Euclid have similar problems with his students? Perhaps, but in Raphael’s painting, The School of Athens, the students look quite attentive and well behaved. In any event, I praised Ruby for seeing the importance of learning and taking action to improve her learning environment. As with all compliments, Ruby accepted this one with praiseworthy modesty.
Part of the process of entering the new school includes Ruby studying for an entrance exam and we, not surprisingly, are working on the practice test’s math problems. The questions include ones that address concepts she has yet to study, which presents quite a hurdle. That hurdle also existed for Euclid as he tried to expand his knowledge of geometry. Starting with what he knew and skills he already possessed, Euclid discovered the mathematical principles that led to Euclidean geometry. So when Ruby faced the need to understand the meaning and utility of a weighted average we began with what she knew and her existing skills. Given two different sets of numbers with five numbers in each set, she readily computed the mean. Asked to determine the mean of all 10 numbers, she did so. I then asked if she thought she would arrive at the same mean if she added the mean she calculated for each set and divided it by two. She thought she would and testing her theory found that she arrived at the same mean as adding all 10 numbers and dividing the sum by 10. Wonderful!
But why was she able to arrive at the same mean? What is the underlying principle making that possible?
Can you, I asked, thinking about the numbers and operations you performed discover the logic leading to the right answer?
She thought, and I hoped. Then she said, I think you can take the mean of the two means because the number of numbers in each set is the same. Well done, young lady, well done! Euclid would be proud. Ruby accepted my heartfelt praise modestly, but inside I hope she feels pride in herself; the pride of genuine accomplishment that builds belief and confidence; the confidence that she can discover the “why” for other problems and in other situations.
Euclid might state Ruby’s discovery in slightly different words. We can take the mean of the means because the weight of each set comprising those means is the same. However, if there were five numbers in one set and three in the other we would need to calculate a weight for each set. The weight for the first set that contains five numbers is 0.625 and for the second set 0.375. Multiplying each weight times the mean for its respective set and adding the resulting numbers yields the weighted mean. As Euclid and Lincoln would attest, it’s simply a matter of logic.
Ruby’s moment of discovery is among the best moments in my teaching experience, which includes not only tutoring since I retired, but also teaching evening business courses while working full-time in banking. It joins those magical moments when, as a teacher, you’re privileged to behold a student’s epiphany; a moment created by students themselves; a moment when they discover the “why” that is math’s underlying logic. In that wonderful epiphany, the door is unlocked to reveal math’s inner workings.
