geralt / Pixabay
Erika A. Patall is a USC education professor who co-wrote a book chapter for Oxford Press titled 26 Instructional Practices That Support Adaptive Motivation, Engagement, and Learning, and a short summary for Ed Source called Grades vs. learning: AI reveals the flaws in our education system.
The chapter is behind a paywall, but I gained access and had ChatGPT write a good summary for teachers. The authors identify five elements of student motivation, adding “Mindset” to the traditional categories used in Self-Determination Theory.
I’m adding this info to Best Posts On “Motivating” Students.
Here’s ChatGPT’s summary:
The chapter actually identifies five major motivational elements, not four:
- Perceived Competence
- Autonomy
- Interest and Value
- Growth Mindset / Adaptive Attributions / Mastery Goals
- Relatedness and Belonging
For classroom use, I would condense them into the following practical framework:
1. Help Students Feel Capable (Perceived Competence)
Students work harder when they believe they can succeed.
What teachers should do
Provide clear structure
- Post learning targets.
- Establish routines.
- Make expectations predictable.
Give appropriately challenging work
- Not too easy.
- Not too hard.
- Support students with scaffolds and models.
Give informative feedback
Instead of:
Good job.
Try:
Your evidence supports your claim well. Next, add an explanation.
Teach learning strategies
- Goal setting
- Summarizing
- Self-monitoring
- Using prior knowledge
- Self-talk
Use peer models
Let students see classmates successfully solving problems, especially classmates who struggled first.
Quick classroom application
Ask:
What strategy helped you solve this?
more often than:
Who got the right answer?
2. Give Students Meaningful Autonomy
Students are more motivated when they feel ownership.
What teachers should do
Offer meaningful choices
- Topic choice
- Product choice
- Reading choice
- Partner choice
- Question choice
Listen to student perspectives
- Ask for opinions.
- Validate concerns.
- Incorporate suggestions.
Use autonomy-supportive language
Instead of:
You must do this.
Try:
One approach you might try is…
Let students shape learning
- Student-generated questions
- Choice boards
- Project pathways
Avoid unnecessary control
The chapter repeatedly emphasizes reducing controlling language and practices.
Quick classroom application
Whenever possible, provide:
“Choose one of these three options.”
instead of:
“Everyone does the exact same thing.”
3. Build Interest and Value
Students engage when they see learning as interesting or useful.
What teachers should do
Connect content to students’ lives
- Hobbies
- Communities
- Future careers
- Current events
Use personalization
- Student-selected examples
- Student interests
- Cultural connections
Have students generate relevance
This is especially important.
Instead of telling students:
This matters because…
ask:
How might this matter in your life?
The research strongly favors students creating their own connections.
Emphasize utility
Ask:
- When might you use this?
- Who uses this in the real world?
- Why might this matter in the future?
Quick classroom application
End lessons with:
- What did you learn?
- Why might it matter?
- How does it connect to your life?
4. Promote Growth Mindset and Mastery
Students persist more when they believe ability can grow.
What teachers should do
Teach that ability develops
Emphasize:
- Practice
- Strategy use
- Persistence
- Learning from mistakes
Use process praise
Instead of:
You’re smart.
Try:
Your revision strategy really improved the paper.
The chapter notes that process praise is much more productive than ability praise.
Teach adaptive attributions
When students fail:
Instead of:
I’m bad at math.
Help them think:
I need a different strategy.
Focus on mastery rather than competition
Emphasize:
- Improvement
- Learning
- Growth
rather than:
- Ranking
- Comparison
- Being the best
Quick classroom application
When returning work:
Ask:
What did you improve?
before asking:
What grade did you get?
5. Create Belonging and Relationships
Students learn more when they feel they belong.
What teachers should do
Build caring relationships
- Learn names quickly.
- Show interest in students.
- Check in regularly.
Create inclusive participation
Make sure all students have opportunities to contribute.
Normalize help-seeking
Students should feel that asking for help is a sign of learning, not weakness.
Use collaborative learning carefully
- Clear roles
- Clear expectations
- Equal participation
Provide representation
Students should see people like themselves succeeding in academic domains.
Quick classroom application
Every student should regularly hear:
I’m glad you’re here.
Your ideas matter.
You can do this.
