Study Outlines Specific Student Motivation Strategies

geralt / Pixabay

Erika A. Patall is a USC education professor who co-wrote a book chapter for Oxford Press titled 26 Instructional Practices That Support Adaptive Motivation, Engagement, and Learning, and a short summary for Ed Source called Grades vs. learning: AI reveals the flaws in our education system.

The chapter is behind a paywall, but I gained access and had ChatGPT write a good summary for teachers. The authors identify five elements of student motivation, adding “Mindset” to the traditional categories used in Self-Determination Theory.

I’m adding this info to Best Posts On “Motivating” Students.

Here’s ChatGPT’s summary:

The chapter actually identifies five major motivational elements, not four:

  1. Perceived Competence
  2. Autonomy
  3. Interest and Value
  4. Growth Mindset / Adaptive Attributions / Mastery Goals
  5. Relatedness and Belonging

For classroom use, I would condense them into the following practical framework:

1. Help Students Feel Capable (Perceived Competence)

Students work harder when they believe they can succeed.

What teachers should do

Provide clear structure

  • Post learning targets.
  • Establish routines.
  • Make expectations predictable.

Give appropriately challenging work

  • Not too easy.
  • Not too hard.
  • Support students with scaffolds and models.

Give informative feedback
Instead of:

Good job.

Try:

Your evidence supports your claim well. Next, add an explanation.

Teach learning strategies

  • Goal setting
  • Summarizing
  • Self-monitoring
  • Using prior knowledge
  • Self-talk

Use peer models
Let students see classmates successfully solving problems, especially classmates who struggled first.

Quick classroom application

Ask:

What strategy helped you solve this?

more often than:

Who got the right answer?


2. Give Students Meaningful Autonomy

Students are more motivated when they feel ownership.

What teachers should do

Offer meaningful choices

  • Topic choice
  • Product choice
  • Reading choice
  • Partner choice
  • Question choice

Listen to student perspectives

  • Ask for opinions.
  • Validate concerns.
  • Incorporate suggestions.

Use autonomy-supportive language

Instead of:

You must do this.

Try:

One approach you might try is…

Let students shape learning

  • Student-generated questions
  • Choice boards
  • Project pathways

Avoid unnecessary control
The chapter repeatedly emphasizes reducing controlling language and practices.

Quick classroom application

Whenever possible, provide:

“Choose one of these three options.”

instead of:

“Everyone does the exact same thing.”


3. Build Interest and Value

Students engage when they see learning as interesting or useful.

What teachers should do

Connect content to students’ lives

  • Hobbies
  • Communities
  • Future careers
  • Current events

Use personalization

  • Student-selected examples
  • Student interests
  • Cultural connections

Have students generate relevance
This is especially important.

Instead of telling students:

This matters because…

ask:

How might this matter in your life?

The research strongly favors students creating their own connections.

Emphasize utility
Ask:

  • When might you use this?
  • Who uses this in the real world?
  • Why might this matter in the future?

Quick classroom application

End lessons with:

  • What did you learn?
  • Why might it matter?
  • How does it connect to your life?

4. Promote Growth Mindset and Mastery

Students persist more when they believe ability can grow.

What teachers should do

Teach that ability develops
Emphasize:

  • Practice
  • Strategy use
  • Persistence
  • Learning from mistakes

Use process praise

Instead of:

You’re smart.

Try:

Your revision strategy really improved the paper.

The chapter notes that process praise is much more productive than ability praise.

Teach adaptive attributions

When students fail:

Instead of:

I’m bad at math.

Help them think:

I need a different strategy.

Focus on mastery rather than competition
Emphasize:

  • Improvement
  • Learning
  • Growth

rather than:

  • Ranking
  • Comparison
  • Being the best

Quick classroom application

When returning work:

Ask:

What did you improve?

before asking:

What grade did you get?


5. Create Belonging and Relationships

Students learn more when they feel they belong.

What teachers should do

Build caring relationships

  • Learn names quickly.
  • Show interest in students.
  • Check in regularly.

Create inclusive participation
Make sure all students have opportunities to contribute.

Normalize help-seeking
Students should feel that asking for help is a sign of learning, not weakness.

Use collaborative learning carefully

  • Clear roles
  • Clear expectations
  • Equal participation

Provide representation
Students should see people like themselves succeeding in academic domains.

Quick classroom application

Every student should regularly hear:

I’m glad you’re here.
Your ideas matter.
You can do this.

Don’t miss these tips!

We don’t spam! Read more in our privacy policy

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Hot this week

How Mauricio Pochettino could line up Man Utd against Liverpool

With Mauricio Pochettino officially taking the reins at Old...

Oura Ring Adds a Jet Lag Feature for Time Zone Travelers

Traveling to new places is good for the soul,...

10 Airbnbs in Sweden for a Stylish Winter Getaway

Rooms: 2 bedrooms, half-bathAmenities: Washer/dryer, TV, sound system, fire...

Topics

How Mauricio Pochettino could line up Man Utd against Liverpool

With Mauricio Pochettino officially taking the reins at Old...

Oura Ring Adds a Jet Lag Feature for Time Zone Travelers

Traveling to new places is good for the soul,...

Featured Artist | Darrell Black

Darrell Black Frankfurt, Germanyhttp://darrell-black.pixels.com/@definismart My Darrell Urban Black, an American visual...

AI Is Thriving at Capital One

If one were making a list of the companies...

What are the animals in your home learning from each other?

LEARNING FROM EACH OTHER Leaf, Sunshine, and Cuddles The animals who...

Related Articles

Popular Categories

News Feed

ChatGPT can transcribe as you speak now with Live Dictation

ChatGPT’s new Live Dictation feature transcribes audio prompts faster, with no more 10-minute limit.ChatGPT’s new Live Dictation feature transcribes audio prompts faster, with no...

Boulies EP600 ergonomic office chair deal drops for Black Friday — and it’s one of the best mid-range picks we’ve ever tested

Share this article Join the conversation Follow us Add us as a preferred source on Google Newsletter Subscribe to our newsletter The Boulies EP600 is one of our top office...

Anthropic’s IPO puts AI’s circular financing boom to the test

Arriving at public markets today, Anthropic’s IPO is poised to raise billions for the company and its investors. But the biggest surprise may be...

The Analogue 3D can now update itself over Wi-Fi

The console’s latest update finally activates its dormant Wi-Fi hardware, enabling a handful of new features.The console’s latest update finally activates its dormant Wi-Fi...

With the biggest IPO of all time, Anthropic’s ‘good guy’ reputation is on the line

Anthropic’s unusual power structure gives it free rein to shape AI’s future.by Hayden FieldNov 19, 2026, 2:25 PM UTCAnthropic’s unusual power structure gives...

The wait begins for GTA VI on PC

EntertainmentGiven how good the game is on console, the wait will almost certainly be worth it.Given how good the game is on console, the...

Superhuman pushes its Go assistant everywhere

Productivity apps are simultaneously trying to feed more context to their AI tools while also making those AI assistants available in every nook and...

Blue Origin will launch Google’s AI server satellites in 2029

It will be the first dedicated heavy-lift launch for Google’s Project Suncatcher.It will be the first dedicated heavy-lift launch for Google’s Project Suncatcher.by ...

GTA 6 walkthrough: How to complete Catch a Bigger Fish side mission (Cal’s challenge)

Catch a Bigger Fish in GTA 6 is a side mission you can pursue during Chapter One.

GTA 6 walkthrough: How to complete Clear Skies mission

GTA 6's Clear Skies mission is one of the best missions of Chapter 1. This mission sends you soaring through the skies of Leonida.

ICC World Test Championship points table (updated) as of November 19 after SA vs BAN 2026 1st Test

South Africa secured a comfortable nine-wicket win over Bangladesh in the first Test at the Wanderers in Johannesburg.

76ers provide an update on star guard following hamstring injury

The Sixers offered an update on Jaylen Brown's hamstring injury, which kept him out of Wednesday night's match.

The Pets Table launches in Whole Foods Market

After successful introductions in PetSmart and Walmart, the brand is adding its shelf-stable products to 500 Whole Foods’ stores.

A Pup Above launches first-ever dog treats

The launch features six recipes across two product lines, Crispy Meat Strips and Soft & Chewy Skinny Cookies.

Survey: Pet owners, veterinarians value sustainability, but need more to drive purchase, recommendation

Presented during Pet Food Collab 2026, the survey’s results presented new insights into pet owners’ and veterinarians’ sustainability perceptions.

Qatar’s Film Committee & UAE-Based Yango Play Explore Partnership Kicking Off With Falconry Doc Series ‘Elzam’

The Film Committee at Media City Qatar has signed a memorandum of understanding with UAE-based regional streaming service Yango Play to explore the development,...

Week 11 Super Bowl stock report: Kirk Cousins raises Vikings’ ceiling, Drake Maye injury tanks Patriots

We assess the NFL title race after Week 10 and identify three upcoming games that could reshape the Super Bowl picture

Grading NFL quarterbacks on rookie contracts: Caleb Williams, C.J. Stroud kick careers into high gear

A few young quarterbacks have aced their tests in 2026

“I did not know that was happening” – 27-Year-Old WWE Star Reveals Unscripted John Cena Moment

John Cena recently surprised a 27-year-old WWE star with an unscripted moment. The youngster revealed more details about the moment on social media.

Julius Randle offers blunt thoughts on Nets’ 30-point loss vs. Chicago

Julius Randle didn't hold any punches when asked his thoughts on the Nets' 30-point blowout against the Bulls.

Emi Martínez names Argentina star who could become Lionel Messi’s successor to the No. 10 jersey after win over Costa Rica

Emiliano Martínez has chosen Nico Paz as the player who could inherit Lionel Messi’s iconic No.

Popular articles

ChatGPT can transcribe as you speak now with Live Dictation

ChatGPT’s new Live Dictation feature transcribes audio prompts faster, with no more 10-minute limit.ChatGPT’s new Live Dictation feature transcribes audio prompts faster, with no...

Boulies EP600 ergonomic office chair deal drops for Black Friday — and it’s one of the best mid-range picks we’ve ever tested

Share this article Join the conversation Follow us Add us as a preferred source on Google Newsletter Subscribe to our newsletter The Boulies EP600 is one of our top office...

Anthropic’s IPO puts AI’s circular financing boom to the test

Arriving at public markets today, Anthropic’s IPO is poised to raise billions for the company and its investors. But the biggest surprise may be...

The Analogue 3D can now update itself over Wi-Fi

The console’s latest update finally activates its dormant Wi-Fi hardware, enabling a handful of new features.The console’s latest update finally activates its dormant Wi-Fi...

With the biggest IPO of all time, Anthropic’s ‘good guy’ reputation is on the line

Anthropic’s unusual power structure gives it free rein to shape AI’s future.by Hayden FieldNov 19, 2026, 2:25 PM UTCAnthropic’s unusual power structure gives...

The wait begins for GTA VI on PC

EntertainmentGiven how good the game is on console, the wait will almost certainly be worth it.Given how good the game is on console, the...

Superhuman pushes its Go assistant everywhere

Productivity apps are simultaneously trying to feed more context to their AI tools while also making those AI assistants available in every nook and...

Blue Origin will launch Google’s AI server satellites in 2029

It will be the first dedicated heavy-lift launch for Google’s Project Suncatcher.It will be the first dedicated heavy-lift launch for Google’s Project Suncatcher.by ...

GTA 6 walkthrough: How to complete Catch a Bigger Fish side mission (Cal’s challenge)

Catch a Bigger Fish in GTA 6 is a side mission you can pursue during Chapter One.

GTA 6 walkthrough: How to complete Clear Skies mission

GTA 6's Clear Skies mission is one of the best missions of Chapter 1. This mission sends you soaring through the skies of Leonida.

ICC World Test Championship points table (updated) as of November 19 after SA vs BAN 2026 1st Test

South Africa secured a comfortable nine-wicket win over Bangladesh in the first Test at the Wanderers in Johannesburg.

76ers provide an update on star guard following hamstring injury

The Sixers offered an update on Jaylen Brown's hamstring injury, which kept him out of Wednesday night's match.

The Pets Table launches in Whole Foods Market

After successful introductions in PetSmart and Walmart, the brand is adding its shelf-stable products to 500 Whole Foods’ stores.

A Pup Above launches first-ever dog treats

The launch features six recipes across two product lines, Crispy Meat Strips and Soft & Chewy Skinny Cookies.

Survey: Pet owners, veterinarians value sustainability, but need more to drive purchase, recommendation

Presented during Pet Food Collab 2026, the survey’s results presented new insights into pet owners’ and veterinarians’ sustainability perceptions.

Qatar’s Film Committee & UAE-Based Yango Play Explore Partnership Kicking Off With Falconry Doc Series ‘Elzam’

The Film Committee at Media City Qatar has signed a memorandum of understanding with UAE-based regional streaming service Yango Play to explore the development,...

Week 11 Super Bowl stock report: Kirk Cousins raises Vikings’ ceiling, Drake Maye injury tanks Patriots

We assess the NFL title race after Week 10 and identify three upcoming games that could reshape the Super Bowl picture

Grading NFL quarterbacks on rookie contracts: Caleb Williams, C.J. Stroud kick careers into high gear

A few young quarterbacks have aced their tests in 2026

“I did not know that was happening” – 27-Year-Old WWE Star Reveals Unscripted John Cena Moment

John Cena recently surprised a 27-year-old WWE star with an unscripted moment. The youngster revealed more details about the moment on social media.

Julius Randle offers blunt thoughts on Nets’ 30-point loss vs. Chicago

Julius Randle didn't hold any punches when asked his thoughts on the Nets' 30-point blowout against the Bulls.

Emi Martínez names Argentina star who could become Lionel Messi’s successor to the No. 10 jersey after win over Costa Rica

Emiliano Martínez has chosen Nico Paz as the player who could inherit Lionel Messi’s iconic No.